An analysis of abortion in human life

Most debates on the ethics of abortion focus on whether the fetus is a person. Ultrasonic testing shows that the real first movement of the fetus is somewhere between the 6th and 9th week. Unfortunately, exploring this issue is beyond the scope of our concern here; see Kass If abortion continues to be the number one priority for so many Christians at the expense of the issues the Bible does instruct on, are those who make it their only priority not giving the issue an almost idolatrous seat.

What are the criteria for being a person. The argument is wrong.

Abortion - a matter of human rights and social justice

Abortion as birth control. It will be necessary to show as well that there are no relevant other condi- tions that justify the killing.

Do you have information you want to share with HuffPost. Finally I offer my great thanks to the editor, Stephen Napier, for his comments and allowing me to contribute to this worthwhile project.

Human Personhood Begins at Conception

We confirm that the prohibition of abortion does not affect, in any way, the availability of optimal care to pregnant women. Rather we must approach each case individu- ally and ask whether in this case the goods being pursued are commensurate with the ones that abortion cuts off.

Thus, it can be relevant as one issue among others. This is true even with some more developed forms of utilitarianism e. On the contrary, it is true without qualification that to do any of them is to be in error Aristotle,a However, one may state that there are no strong compulsive reasons which could morally condemn the whole practice of abortion.

It may help to see this if we focus on an infant. What is the mark to having the right attitude to these facts and what manifests having the wrong attitude to them. Such attacks cannot help but lull the social conscience in ways ultimately destructive of other human rights. The answer seems obvious: It seems obvious in this case that the raped woman has a right to abort.

Encyclical Letter Laudato Si, May 24, This can also be seen according to the notion person. In many situations they still talk as if they believe this, but what they really believe in is the great intrinsic value of personhood-the sacred right to self-determination.

The Primacy of the Abortion Issue in the Church

So, while health care, the right to a good education, housing all of these issues are very, very important, they are meaningless if the right to life is not first protected. Methods to abort unwanted or undesired pregnancies have been recorded in the earliest of human civilizations, dating back to the ancient Egyptians.

I am also grateful to the anonymous referee, whose comments were truly helpful in refining and improving the final draft. The Modified Standard Argument However, it seems appropriate to modify the standard argument and to use a more sophisticated version.

In what follows I attempt to answer that question by considering both what has been said and what we may further argue from a virtue-focused perspective. Should they be respected or be refused. We mourn the loss of life that God has created.

If abortion as birth control was considered acceptable by a large number of Lutherans within the Churchwide Assembly, what about abortion for other unsavory reasons. One may object to this claim, that the proponents of this view redefine the empirical feature of "the ability to suffer" as a normative feature is-ought fallacy.

The ELCA and Abortion

Human life is the condition for enjoying freedom and all other values. If the presumption is right that legal rights are tied to the notion of personhood and that there is a difference between rights and quasi-rights, then it seems right that the fetus has no legal right but "just" a quasi-right to live.

Ethical Analysis of Abortion

There is such a wide spectrum of issues involving the protection of human life and the promotion of human dignity. Her pregnancy is an obstacle to this and she decides to have an abortion.

It is like hiring a hitman to solve a problem. To force her at the risk of her life means to force her to give up her right of self-defense and her right to live. Indeed, when we look more closely at her position, I think we will find that undefended assumptions affecting both of these issues get smuggled in.

If there are none, the whole line of reasoning would "hang in the air" so that one could also easily argue for the right to live for cats and dogs. He builds us according to His image, then we act on it though in a deeply flawed way, being sinners.

All ethical theories try to present a proper account of a so-called neutral stance but there is hardly any theory that could claim to be sustainable with regard to other approaches.

In one fell swoop she seemingly obviates much of the previous debate, which focused on establishing whether or not the fetus is a person. Most, except maybe some on the very far left, believe that once a child is able to live on its own outside the womb, abortion should be out of the question with the exception of cases of the viability of the fetus and health of the mother.

The discourses on induced abortion in Ugandan daily newspapers: a discourse analysis. Another significant discourse on abortion revolves around human rights, on the one hand the right to life of the unborn child and on the other the pregnant woman’s right to health and life.

(Human Life International) in Africa, (), described the. Cancer is human life. Depends on whether you consider “human” to mean genetically human or functionally human. Cancer and zygotes equate to the former, sufficiently advanced fetuses in the latter. The Primacy of the Abortion Issue in the Church.

The Declaration on Procured Abortion published by the Vatican's Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith stated, "The first right of the human person is his life.

He has other goods and some are more precious, but this one is fundamental - the condition of all the others.". The status of human life between conception and birth is central to the abortion debate. Whilst some form of life is clearly present at conception, whether that form of life should get the full protection of the law as a ‘person’ is disputed.

The term abortion most commonly refers to the induced abortion of a human pregnancy. After viability, the relevant procedure is referred to as a "late termination of pregnancy".[1][note 1] Modern medicine utilizes medications and surgical procedures for induced abortion.

P. Ruiz Stevens Phil 12/5/11 Ethical Analysis of Abortion Abortion could not be ethically justified because it is killing an innocent human being.

It is arguable that a right to an abortion is a right to control one’s body and the death of fetus is an unavoidable consequence of choosing not to .

An analysis of abortion in human life
Rated 4/5 based on 38 review
ABORTION - Is the unborn human less than human? •